In Tharparkar: Treating Cancer with Disprin


By: Shabbir Ahmad Wahgra

The women of Tharparkar dress in vibrant colours. The more barren and colourless their lives, the more they have a need to dress in brightly coloured clothes. Perhaps this is a defense mechanism – hunger and poverty can suck the colour out of peoples’ lives. Yet, the colour of hope lives on in their faces – the most beautiful colour. Perhaps, this is what helps them survive.

Travelling to Tharparkar for the first time, I experience excitement and nervousness in anticipation. As the scenery whizzes past on our six-hour journey by Jeep from Karachi to Mithi, The landscape soon begins to change as we approach district Tharparkar in Sindh. The spectacular fields full of banana plants we saw in Thatta and Sajawal are replaced by white sand dunes, dry shrubs, Neem trees, cacti of different varieties, sand, sand and more sand. Out of nowhere, a peacock suddenly appears and a myriad of blue and green splashes its feathers – against the barren desert backdrop, it is definitely a treat. Camels lazily trudge along the way. Men pass by in brightly coloured shalwar kameezes. Few villagers were fetching water from a deep well with the help of their camel, the water which they as well as their animals will drink from the storage tank which every household locked on the brink of the well.
I can hardly spot public transport except few “keekdaas”, a British era transport trucks which are still used in Tharparkar. I peer for an oasis or a pond on the way. I was hardly able to spot a couple.
This desert district in Sindh might be the most impoverished in Pakistan, but at the same time it’s perhaps the most peaceful place in the entire country. Tharis keep their doors unlocked. Their only wealth, their cattle are seen grazing in the fields without herdsmen. There are hardly any police pickets and no concept of police patrolling with crime rate at only two percent.

During a visit to main hospital in Mitti, the misery was written on the faces of Thari mothers as all the mothers present at the Mithi Civil Hospital tell tales of malnutrition. “A healthy mother means a healthy child. Thari mothers are underweight.

But the situation inside villages is even worse. Kumari is a Lady Health Worker (LHW) in the village Borli Bheel in union council Chelhar some 20 kilometers from Mithi, working on a project funded by World Food Program. Her house is exceptionally clean and this is typical of the houses of the Meghwar Hindu community in Tharparkar. The district, incidentally, has a majority of Hindus as its population. Muslims and Hindus co-exist peacefully in this region.

In this small hundred household village Kumari welcomes us, some thirty women have already gathered at her house to meet us. “Community living” is the word that comes to my mind instantaneously – something that is on its way out in the cities.
While the world is trying to understand string of deaths and malnutrition emergency in Tharparkar, which everyone thinks is all due to drought, poverty, lack of food and health facilities. I, myself, have the same assumption before this visit but the ground realities are bit different. No one can deny the existence of above-mentioned problems but few other reasons, which are complicating the health of infants, are very less focused.

One of the core reasons of the malnourished children are a result of mothers continuously giving birth to many children without spacing. “The minimum gap is usually nine to fifteen months. A child doesn’t get breastfed enough in case of another hasty pregnancy”.

Sunil, a male villager told me in funny way, “Our women quite commonly give birth to up to twelve children,” he said and laughed, saying there was a woman in Khurbiyoon village who has borne eighteen children.

The food of a pregnant woman is normally just one to two rotis and a glass of milk if she is lucky. The average Thari woman doesn’t visit a doctor even in case of a problem but calls the Daai who can only advise the woman some native remedy.

A usually untrained midwife who is locally called a Daai is the all-in-one caretaker for a pregnant woman, whose wisdom and experience is never questioned. The woman expecting a baby has to follow whatever the Daai advises. The Daai, a Guru of sorts, commands a certain respect and authority in the communities, and often predicts, without an ultrasound, what the gender of the newborn will be.

The total fee of a Daai is between five hundred to one thousand rupees depending upon experience and reputation. If the newborn is a son, an extra Chunni (dupatta) and dry dates are given as a gift in gratitude.

“The family and relatives find out if a son is born by the Daai beating a plate,” said Kumari, explaining the traditions. “If she comes out without a sign, people turn back and understand the new guest is a daughter.”

There are few very strange traditions, which are also contributing in malnutrition and retarded growth of children in Tharparkar. The midwives of the desert use centuries-old remedies for newborns, which are often detrimental to mother and child’s health.
Traditionally, a Thari baby is not breastfed for at least 48 hours after birth. Many mothers, who follow instructions of Daais religiously, believe the first milk is toxic for their children. Thus, the newborns lose out on the proven benefits of the first milk called Colostrum, which contains important antibodies to protect the newborn against disease, and is lower in fat and higher in protein compared to ordinary milk.

“A mother is advised not to feed the baby immediately after birth. It could be injurious,” Junta, a fifty years old Daai with more than thirty years of experience said. “It is better to give milk [of goat] and gurr to the newborn,” she stressed. She shared that newborns are also immediately given desi ghee. “The mother dips her finger in ghee and puts it in child’s mouth.” The newborns are also given drops of hot water till their mothers are allowed to feed them.

Another tradition which effects the health of new born is the local custom of feeding a baby born anytime during the day after watching the first star on the sky after sunset and if a baby born at night he or she has to wait till next night so this 12 to 24 hours wait becomes fatal for the infants.
Usually, pediatricians advise that a newborn should be breastfed for 24 months but this practice doesn’t exist in the desert. “Six months are enough; mothers start giving pieces of roti to babies within two months,” said Noor, mother of a newborn, while she was waiting for a doctor outside the Civil Hospital, Mithi.

“Only two children died due to malnutrition while all other deaths are due multiple factors” said Lola Castro, country director of world food program who was also on the visit of this drought affected area. She said WFP, government and other agencies are doing lot of efforts but this multifactorial problem can only be solved through multifactorial strategy including massive mobilization campaign using local people.

Each year hundreds of social development programmes are initiated in Tharparkar with donations from international development groups, but no programme is properly addressing the main issue of awareness and busy in treating cancer with disprin.

The government and other aid agencies intervention through wheat and food supplements distribution need to be supported by massive awareness campaign to break the taboos only then these precious lives can be saved in this calamity hit area.

(The writer is a Journalist with more than 13 years of experience in print and electronic media)

Genocide in Gaza


By: Shabbir Ahmad Wahgra

In Last one month, the score in Gaza is closer to 1800 — 40 per cent of them children; and there is no sign that the international community or its associated arms of human rights or justice are any near to intervening. The shooting down of a Malaysian plane leads the newscast in the Western world and newer sanctions on Russia are conveniently afoot instead.

The utter shame is silence of Muslim world and its leaders as so far we have seen thousands of people Around the world in locations as far away as South Africa, Chile, Indonesia, Japan and London, demonstrations have taken place in solidarity with the Palestinians. Even Thousands of people protested Israel’s actions in the Gaza Strip in Tel Aviv and in front of white house, the most big ally of Israel but not anywhere in the whole Muslim world at least not in a significant numbers.
What happens in Palestine is not Shiite vs. Sunnis; that is why the Islamic world keeps silent. Children are dying in Palestine; Humanity has been destroyed there, as well as the honor of Muslims but the leadership is showing a blind eye on all this genocide as they have no heart except few statements from very few Muslim head of states. OIC and Arab League are as toothless as ever so their response is as oer expectations.

As much as ammunition in Gaza is concern it is physically not possible to transport weapons to this place as Gaza is blocked on three sides by Israel. On the fourth side sits the Mediterranean, controlled and managed by Israel, completing a perfect siege. It is practically now the world’s largest prison with 1.8 million inhabitants. Egypt has a 12km-wide stretch of border with Gaza but it blocks it more assiduously than even the Israelis.

What a befitting response can do, we can judge from this comparison from 2012 Israeli attack. Battling Palestinian militants in Gaza two years ago, Israel found itself pressed from all sides by unfriendly Arab neighbors to end the fighting and Israel ended its offensive with casualty figures 177.
But not this time as no real pressure exerted by neighboring Arab countries despite killing of more than 500 innocent children in Gaza.
After the military ouster of the Islamist government in Cairo last year, Egypt has led a new coalition of Arab states — including Jordan, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates — that has effectively lined up with Israel in its fight against Hamas, the Islamist movement that controls the Gaza Strip. That, in turn, may have contributed to the failure of the antagonists to reach a negotiated cease-fire even after more than three weeks of bloodshed.
Egyptian officials have directly or implicitly blamed Hamas instead of Israel for Palestinian deaths in the fighting, even when, for example, United Nations schools have been hit by Israeli shells, something that occurred again on Sunday.
The reluctance of major regional countries such as Saudi Arabia and Egypt to take a bold mediator position to end the assault on Gaza has given other regional parties an opportunity to step in. Turkey as well as Qatar, which has good relations with Hamas, Israel and the United States, are trying to take up the role that Egypt usually plays, but both have been rebuffed by Israel. The United States has also tried to mediate the conflict, even though its administration has made it clear that it supports Israel’s right to defend itself.
Pakistan’s offer of aid to Gaza and condemnation of Israeli violence must be respected because the country is not just stepping out of the Saudi line, but also their policy is in direct opposition to the US stance, its two big allies.

Pakistan’s efforts at international front are also significant as we are the country facing the most difficult challenges within out borders than any other Muslim country like insurgency in Baluchistan and of course, Waziristan, where the our military is fighting the decisive and one of the difficult battle against militants. Where as government is fighting with bad economy, humanitarian crisis in the shape of IDPs and political chaos created by one of the main opposition party PTI and an imported religious leader Tahir ul Qadri.
As humans we strive to exist peacefully. And that is why we must speak out against oppression. It is a matter of reminding us of humanity, the sole feature that separates us from animals.